What do Johnston & Murphy items sell for?
2 categories priced from 75 sold listings on Poshmark, eBay and HiBid, updated Nov 18, 2026.
Johnston & Murphy resale prices by category
Typical price is the median sale. Pick a category for its marketplace breakdown.
Where Johnston & Murphy sells best
Poshmark carried 49% of Johnston & Murphy sales.
Bars are each marketplace's share of sold listings. "Paid most" counts the categories where it had the highest sold price, of 1 where two or more sold.
What affects Johnston & Murphy resale value
Read from the Johnston & Murphy sales above.
The category
Johnston & Murphy flats sell for about $47; Johnston & Murphy shoes for about $35. That is 1.4× apart under the same label.
The exact item
Even within shoes, most sales land anywhere from $21 to $80, a 3.9× spread. Model, size and condition decide where yours falls.
Timing
Recent price checks show Johnston & Murphy prices rising in 1 category (shoes) and steady in 1.
Asking vs sold
Live Johnston & Murphy listings ask about 131% more than the same items sell for on the same marketplace. Price from what sold, not from what is listed.
How these prices are calculated
Built from 3 price checks run in the ResaleOS pricing engine between Sep 26, 2026 and Nov 18, 2026, covering 75 sold and 350 active listings on Poshmark, eBay, HiBid, Grailed, ResaleOS, OfferUp, Vinted, Depop, Etsy, Craigslist, Bonanza and Vestiaire Collective. A category's typical price is the median across its checks. Individual listings are not republished.
Selling Johnston & Murphy in volume? ResaleOS inventory suggests a price for every item you add from the same sold listings.